I agree. Though, in practice, at least in internet arguments, people tend to “diagnose” people so they can dismiss them in some manner, rather than grapple with the argument being presented. In the “Oh, you are just a so and so, I don’t need to entertain this” kinda manner.

We didn’t think Half Life 1 looked realistic against reality, just that it was the most realistic graphics we had seen yet.

It’s not like we looked at the game and went that’s indistinguishable from reality.